Skip to content
editorial
price tracking
ecommerce
personalized pricing

Personalized vs dynamic pricing: what's legal

By Webtingle Team · · 11 min read

Is the price different for you? Sometimes it is. Personalized pricing means a store sets a price for one shopper from what it knows about them.

In December 2025, 437 volunteers shopped Instacart at the same moment, adding identical groceries from the same stores to their carts. At one Seattle Safeway, a box of Wheat Thins came up at prices as much as 23% apart from one shopper to the next.

Often the price you see is the price everyone sees, and it has simply moved since yesterday. That is dynamic pricing. From a single screen the two look alike, but they key on different signals and the law has started to treat them differently.

Dynamic pricing vs personalized pricing

Dynamic pricing changes the price over time for everyone, while personalized pricing changes it between people at the same moment.

A store can move a price for four reasons, and only the last one is about you:

What moves the priceWho gets the new priceKind
Competitors' pricesEveryoneDynamic
Stock running low or piling upEveryoneDynamic
Demand and the calendarEveryoneDynamic
Who is lookingYou, or shoppers the store thinks are like youPersonalized

The quickest way to tell them apart is the same-moment test. Two people look at the same item, in the same store, at the same moment. If their prices match each other but differ from last week's, the price is dynamic. If their prices differ from each other, the price is personalized, or the store is running a test.

A randomized test looks exactly like personalization from the outside. Instacart described its experiments as randomized and said it does not use personal or demographic data to set prices, and it ended item price tests on its platform later that month. The shoppers in the expensive group would still have paid more for the same box.

"Surveillance pricing" is the name the FTC and several state legislatures use for personalized pricing that runs on personal data, and economists call the wider practice of charging different people different prices for the same thing price discrimination. Most of the laws below use one of the first two terms.

If your question is why a price moved since yesterday, that is the dynamic kind, and catching those moves as they happen is a separate job.

What personalized prices actually key on

The signals with public evidence behind them are whether you are signed in, which device you use, what you did on the store's own site, and whatever a pricing vendor knows about where you are and who you are.

In a 2014 study, researchers at Northeastern University compared what more than 300 real shoppers and a set of controlled test accounts saw on 16 large retail and travel sites. They found some form of personalization on nine of them:

  • Membership. Cheaptickets and Orbitz showed lower hotel prices to signed-in members.
  • Device. Travelocity cut prices by about $15 on roughly 5% of hotels for shoppers on iPhones and iPads. Home Depot showed mobile browsers a pricier mix of products.
  • Your history on the site. Priceline changed search results based on what a shopper had clicked and bought.
  • A test bucket. Expedia and Hotels.com put a subset of users into an A/B test that pushed them toward more expensive hotels.

Expedia and Hotels.com were steering rather than pricing. They left each hotel's price alone and changed which hotels came first, so shoppers who book from the top of the list end up paying more. Home Depot did both: it steered mobile browsers toward pricier products and showed Android users prices about 41 cents higher on roughly 6% of items.

In findings published in January 2025, FTC staff described pricing intermediaries, among them Mastercard, Accenture, PROS, Bloomreach, Revionics and McKinsey, working with at least 250 clients on prices set from data ranging "from a person's location and demographics, down to their mouse movements on a webpage." Products left unbought in a cart can be tracked and used to adjust pricing too. In October 2026 the Commission ordered the sellers themselves, Delta, United, JetBlue, Lyft, Uber, DoorDash, Instacart, Target and Walmart, to explain whether their prices vary from person to person, with 45 days to answer.

Does incognito mode get you a lower price?

Incognito mode can get you a lower price, and it can also cost you one. A private window drops your cookies and signs you out, which removes history signals of the Priceline kind. In a 2023 peer-reviewed audit of Kayak, University of Illinois researchers found that the profile with no browsing history got the best flight prices on average, while profiles with a history did better on hotels. Signing out also drops member pricing, which in the Northeastern study was the clearest case of personalization lowering a price. Your device, your location and any test bucket stay as they were.

Common beliefWhat the evidence shows
Going incognito gets a lower priceSometimes. On Kayak it did for flights and not for hotels, and it can cost you a members-only rate, as at Cheaptickets and Orbitz
Phones get worse pricesDevice mattered at two of 16 sites in 2014, and at Travelocity the iPhone price was the lower one
Two shoppers, two prices means personalizationIt can be a randomized test, as at Instacart in 2025 and Expedia and Hotels.com in 2014
Personal data is only used to raise pricesMember rates and targeted discounts are personalized prices too, and several of the new state laws leave room for them

The practical rule is to check the price signed in and signed out, and pay whichever is lower.

Personalized and surveillance pricing laws

As of 9 November 2026, personalized pricing is legal in most of the US. New York requires a label, Maryland's ban covers groceries, and bans in Connecticut and New Jersey start in 2027. The EU requires disclosure rather than a ban.

WhereRuleStatus
New YorkAlgorithmic Pricing Disclosure Act: a price set from personal data must say "THIS PRICE WAS SET BY AN ALGORITHM USING YOUR PERSONAL DATA"In force since 10 Nov 2025
New YorkOne Fair Price Act (A.9349): bans personalized algorithmic pricingAwaiting the governor, due by end of 2026
MarylandProtection From Predatory Pricing Act (HB 895): food retailers and delivery services may not use personal data to set higher pricesIn force since 1 Oct 2026
ConnecticutHB 5563: bans surveillance pricing by retailers and delivery services, with exceptionsFrom 1 Jul 2027
New JerseyFair Price Protection Act: bans surveillance pricing for groceries and other foodFrom 1 Aug 2027
ColoradoHB 26-1210: would have made surveillance pricing a deceptive trade practiceVetoed 2 Jun 2026
CaliforniaAB 2564: would have banned surveillance pricing by retailersDied Aug 2026
US (FTC)Personalized pricing inquiry: orders to nine airline, ride-hail, delivery and retail companiesOpened 28 Oct 2026
EUConsumer Rights Directive, Art. 6(1)(ea): shops must say when "the price was personalised on the basis of automated decision-making"In force since 28 May 2022
EUDigital Fairness Act: expected to add rules on dynamic and personalized pricingProposal due mid-Nov 2026

Compiled by Webtingle from the sources linked in each row. Last checked 9 November 2026.

New York's disclosure law carries fines of up to $1,000 per violation and survived a First Amendment challenge in district court; the retail industry's appeal, NRF v. James, was argued on 19 October 2026. New Jersey's law also lets consumers sue and pauses new electronic shelf labels for a year. The FTC has had a proposed enforcement policy statement on personalized pricing out for comment since August.

As of November 2026, one US ban on personalized pricing is in force, Maryland's, and it covers groceries. The rest of the law in force asks stores to tell you, and neither New York's label nor the EU's notice requires anyone to charge the same price.

The "was" price: rules on discounts

A discount is only as honest as the price it is measured against, and this is where the rules are firmest.

  • European Union. Since 28 May 2022, an announced price reduction must show the prior price, defined as "the lowest price applied by the trader during a period of time not shorter than 30 days" before the reduction. When consumer authorities from 25 countries checked 314 online shops, they found that 30% got their discounts wrong, and 18% used pressure tactics such as countdown timers.
  • United Kingdom. On 14 October 2026 the CMA fined Wayfair £4.8 million and Appliances Direct £1.2 million for "daily" and 24-hour deals that were still available at the same or a lower price after the countdown ran out.
  • United States. There is no 30-day rule. The FTC's Guides Against Deceptive Pricing say a former price is a fair basis for a discount only if the item was offered "to the public on a regular basis for a reasonably substantial period of time," and call a price inflated just to advertise a big reduction fictitious.

Around Black Friday this is the part of pricing law you can use directly, as long as you know what the item cost in the weeks before. If your record of an EU shop's price shows anything lower in the 30 days before the sale, the "was" price on that discount breaks the rule. And once you know the floor, setting a target price beats waiting for a sale banner to tell you what a deal is.

How to check whether your price is personalized

Compare the same item at the same moment from two different contexts, and keep a record of the public price over time. A gap that follows one context every time you check, such as signed in versus signed out, tells you what the store is keying on.

  1. Run the same-moment test. Open the item side by side, at the same time: signed in and in a private window, or on your phone and your laptop. If you can, ask someone in another city to check while you do.
  2. Look for the label. In New York, a price set from your personal data must say so in those words. EU shops must tell you when a price was personalized by automated decision-making.
  3. Keep a public baseline. Record the signed-out price over a few weeks, so you know what the item costs anyone. Price-history tools do this for some stores: camelcamelcamel and Keepa for Amazon, Google's price tracking for products in its Shopping results, and page monitors such as Webtingle for any product page you point them at, which keep a dated history of the page. A baseline like that shows the public price from one place, so make sure it sees your country's store and currency. It can't show you what someone else was offered, so the useful signal is your own signed-in price sitting above it.
  4. Keep the evidence and report it. If the prices differ, save a screenshot with the time and the context (signed in, device, location). In the US, the FTC takes reports of "bad business practices" as well as scams at ReportFraud.ftc.gov. In New York, a personalized price without the label is a matter for the state attorney general.

Sources and updates

This page reflects the law as of 9 November 2026, checked against the source linked in each row. We'll update it when New York's governor acts on the One Fair Price Act, when the European Commission publishes its Digital Fairness Act proposal, and when the Second Circuit rules in NRF v. James.

Start free with Webtingle. 14-day trial, no credit card. A signed-out price record on any product page takes about two minutes to set up, and the same monitor covers price and restock alerts on any store.